Elden ring nightreign review metacritic

Elden Ring: Nightreign has received generally favorable but mixed reviews on Metacritic, with a Metascore around 77-78 based on about 74 critic reviews, and a user score slightly lower, reflecting some divided opinions among players[1][2][5].

Critics acknowledge that Nightreign is an interesting and bold departure from the main Elden Ring formula, focusing on a multiplayer co-op roguelike experience where teams of up to three players fight enemies and bosses in repeated runs. This shift to a more frantic, survival-style gameplay has been praised for competent roguelike mechanics and satisfying combat, but also criticized for lacking the depth, variety, and polish of the original Elden Ring and its expansions[2][3][7].

Some key points from reviews include:

• The game is best experienced in co-op mode; solo play is described as poorly balanced and frustrating, which may limit its appeal to hardcore Elden Ring fans who prefer single-player RPGs[7].
• Critics note the reuse of assets from Elden Ring and Dark Souls, which some feel reduces the freshness and variety of the experience[7].
• The pacing and map randomness can lead to uneven experiences, sometimes making runs feel unfair or repetitive[7].
• Despite these issues, many reviewers find the core combat mechanics engaging and the co-op gameplay rewarding when it works well[2][7].

In the context of FromSoftware's history, Nightreign's Metacritic score is the lowest for a major Soulsborne release since 2013, even below Dark Souls Remastered, but it still ranks within the top dozen FromSoftware games overall due to the developer’s strong legacy of highly rated titles[4][5][6].

In summary, Elden Ring: Nightreign is seen as a solid but not outstanding addition to the Elden Ring universe—an experimental multiplayer roguelike that may appeal to fans looking for a fresh take on FromSoftware’s combat but is less likely to satisfy those expecting the depth and single-player focus of the main series.